In the film, the speaker of this line is not visible. The book of the film says this line is by Jack, but in the film the voice sounds like that of Gibbs.
In the film, the speaker of this line is not visible. The book of the film isn't any help because it omits the details of the cage rolling scheme. This line is shouted by someone in a leadership role within the cage after it falls into the water, either Will or Gibbs, and the voice sounds more like that of Gibbs.
In the film, the speaker of this line is not visible. It is from one of the three men lined up and looking over the ship's railing, facing away from the camera, either Bellamy, the Quartermaster, or the Bursar. The book of the film isn't any help because it omits the mention of entrails, and has only the discussion of seaweed. The book doesn't even identify which sailors are making the comments about seaweed.
When Tia lets the monkey out of the cage, the camera shows the monkey and not the crewmembers' faces, so it is not shown who says "No!" It could be Ragetti, but since Gibbs is the one who speaks right after that ("You've no idea how long it took us to catch that."), most likely it was Gibbs who said "No!"
One contributor says the speaker of this line is Clanker, although the book of the film says it is Greenbeard (which the book also says is the bo'sun). The book and film are often in conflict about quotes and characters, however, and in the film the bo'sun is Jimmy Legs, not Greenbeard.
Created: August 8, 2006
Updated: April 19, 2007